This seems like a perfectly calm, uncontroversial topic to write about. Nobody’s got strong feelings about this one at all. But I guess I’ll offer some thoughts / causes for how we got from there to here:
– So a talking point today is a right leaning Supreme Court is acting against the will of the people. Hmm, I don’t remember that talking point being the same when the court voted to legalize gay marriage, or uphold Obamacare. You see this is the problem when too much of national power is ceded to & handled by nine ordinary, average, flawed human beings. They have a lot of power, but only because as the Judicial Branch of government they literally cannot stop functioning. They cannot gridlock like the Legislature or rule incompetently like the Executive since oh say about the year 2000.
– Ideally, Congress should pass legislation that lays out the left and right limits on abortion. In fact, as we pointed out a few weeks ago about gun control (by the way, that they got a gun bill passed shocked me; but I suspect it won’t do all that much in the end), as they hold the keys to both Houses and the Presidency, the Democrats could pass a pro-choice law tomorrow, yes tomorrow. They just need to drop the filibuster, which they won’t, because they need to keep their Senate seats in West Virginia and Arizona. So again, who’s house should people be protesting in front of? Not the Supreme Court justices, but rather Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema. But again, they won’t, because political power comes first.
– Trump’s chance at winning the primary, if not the election as a whole, just went up about 736%. The right’s talking point for so many years was, we hate this guy and/or know he’s a nut, but if he delivers we’ll hold our noses and vote for him. And in the end, Trump delivered on something fifty years in the making. People want results, whatever their side of the argument is, and people will vote for evil demagogues or nutcases, as long as they deliver. History shows it, time and time again.
– Conversely, for the Democrats how should they feel? Trump is gone, they own both Houses and the Presidency, and this happens? The complaint on the Republican side for many years was, we vote these guys (GW Bush, Romney) and then they don’t deliver. So they picked Trump instead. Don’t be surprised if Bernie milks this for all it’s worth, or Warren, or any other nutcase of the left to mirror Trump. The Democrat primary will be out for blood, don’t be surprised if they pick their own Trump equivalent who makes only one singular promise, that they’ll deliver.
– Mitch McConnell would have made a great Roman Senator in the days when political differences were often solved with assassinations. His kneecap of Merrick Garland was wrong, ungentlemanly, against history, and ruthlessly effective. Conversely, the failure of Chuck Schumer to accomplish similar results basically shows him to be the total loser his day-to-day personality portrays.
– The overturn of abortion theoretically should have happened in the 1990’s. One should remember two simple points: Anthony Kennedy was appointed by Reagan. David Souter was appointed by HW Bush. Both these guys became part of the left side of the court. If Reagan and HW Bush had chosen judges to the right side of the court, this conversation would be nearly three decades old by this point.
– Remember Ruth Bader Ginsburg? She could have retired under Obama and lived out her years earing six figure speeches. She died in office under Trump. I suspect a lot of the hero cult and Notorious RGB and other such nonsense did nobody on the left any favors. I live in an American city (which means it leans left) and I still see her face on car bumpers or bubbleheads in stores. But, to serve the causes she believed in, and those her hero worshipers supported, she should have retired. Making a cult of an ordinary, average, flawed human being has consequences.
– Almost every European nation has more restrictive abortion laws than America. For example, in Sweden it’s entirely legal up to the 18th week. The Mississippi law stated it was the 15th week. But if they believe the left talking points, this meant Mississippi’s law was a source of evil. So are Sweden (or Spain, 14 weeks) also dens of evil? There was room for the left to compromise, to admit that abortion could exist, but within certain limits. Polls show the vast, vast majority of Americans would approve of abortion under these more restrictive circumstances. But the left assumed the most extreme, unmovable position, and now it’s cost them everything.
– Expect that abortion by proxy will become commonplace. People will be angry enough to put their money where their mouths are. Companies will get in on the game too, for example, Amazon already has. What’s it cost to fly a woman from Mississippi to Illinois, plus cab fare, plus the abortion fee? I’m guessing less than $500? Who knows. The point is it’ll happen.
– I’ve got two family vacations coming up. I hope the family doesn’t want to talk about politics, but they will. Politics is everywhere now. It’s hiding beneath your bed. Politics knows if you’ve been bad or good. It knows when you’re awake. But the truth is, 99.9% of Americans can do precisely, absolutely nothing about what just happened. I have a hard enough time getting through many days, just to survive the day and not go nuts, than to worry about something I can’t control. This blog post is essentially irrelevant, it doesn’t actually matter or mean anything. For the 99.9% who are powerless to impact abortion policy, all their extreme talk (on one side or the other) is equally irrelevant.
– We’re all doomed.